Monday, October 13, 2008

Conflict of Interest: A Guide to the Vast and Varying Aspects of Criminal Justice

In an attempt at broadening my knowledge of the online world, I explored the blogosphere this week, hunting for resources to assist and expand my understanding of forensics, psychology and the criminal justice system. With the help of the Webby and IMSA criteria, I have compiled 20 diverse websites with explorations into this particular study, all of which are now located in my Linkroll. In direct correlation with my previous posts, the first of these websites is The Innocence Project, which is a personal favorite of mine and is seen to the right. Beyond its visual appealing interface, this website provides a plethora of useful information, not only in terms of current cases, but also in identifying the flaws in the criminal justice system and possible reforms. The combination of strong content and ease of use makes this website a powerful source. Similarly, The Justice Project provides an analysis of exonerations and false convictions as they discuss possibilities for fixing the flaws in the system. Related to my previous post on False Convictions is the American Psychological Association website on Law & Psychology, which outlines current psycholegal news and provides the code of ethics for Psychologists; along the same lines, the American Legal Ethics Library provides an in-depth collection of legal and ethical codes for numerous states and the ACS Blog has a strong focus on the law and legislation surrounding the criminal justice system wrapped up in a neat, attractive interface. Additionally, the Center on Wrongful Convictions explores the cases of exonerated individuals. Also, it identifies the issues behind wrongful convictions, such as the causes and remedies, the death penalty, and what happens to individuals after their exoneration. This exploration provides a strong resource into the problems and specific cases where see the dominance and relevance of such issues.

For a more news-based source, ABC News provides a neatly-organized, engaging and interactive page. Aside from having short video clips and images, it provides news articles separated by topic, allowing for easy access to the article of your choice. Alltop.com also provides a collaboration of different websites, including recent posts and a short excerpt of the article when hovering over the title. The website is less than visually stimulating, with an overwhelming amount of text, however, its usefulness, particularly in the article excerpts, compensates. AlterNet.org (referenced in my post in Eyewitness Misidentification) and the ABA Journal are both online magazines with easy-to-use interfaces, wide ranges of up-to-date articles and very reliable and scholarly sources. Psychology and Crime News provides great analysis and links to multitudes of outside sources, with the downfall of many links failing to provide full sources to the reader. Many links lead only to abstracts of certain articles and the overall appearance of the website is rather dull and fails to engage the reader visually. Also somewhat news related is that of wrongful-convictions, a blog which acts more as a news page in presenting the cases of those wrongfully convicted in the United States.

Entering into the genre of blogs, Grits for Breakfast proves to be the most highly acclaimed and utilized by other bloggers. In addition to being well-maintained and highly informative, it provides a strong opinion while retaining professionalism in language and tone. Equally as useful and renowned would be Underdog Blog, as seen to the left. This blog provides a very light and personable style while at the same time being very informational and voicing a strong opinion. Its professionalism has gained this blog a large fanbase among others in the blogosphere. Similarly, Forensic News Blog presents interesting topics in the field of forensics but does so in a very casual and intriguing fashion. Although lighthearted, it still remains informative and introduces the reader to many unknown facts and facets of forensics. Also, the Eyewitness Identification Reform Blog demonstrated cases dealing with, obviously, eyewitness identification. However, despite their informative blogs and clean interface, their blog lacked significant and recent updates.

The death penalty was a prevalent issue for many blogs, with Capital Defense Weekly, Abolish the Death Penalty, Lethal Injection, and Death Penalty Issues stemming from the controversial topic. In particular, Abolish the Death Penalty portrayed a strong opinion which, although some may say it is too biased, provides a strong counterpoint for any conflicting blog site or webpage. The extensive passion of the blog would make for an excellent comparison and will undoubtedly be well-researched. Lethal Injection gives a strong defense to specific cases which may result in lethal injection. Although this blog pulls from relevant news sources, its methods of doing so allow for strange formatting and differing fonts and sizes, giving the appearance an unprofessional and sloppy look. Likewise, Death Penalty Issues provides the reader with a massive amount of different resources and is an excellent source, not only for death penalty cases, but also for history, facts and general information. However, its downfall is in the rather poor formatting. The website links become slightly confusing and are rather messy on this slightly shocking complicated interface. Finally, Capital Defense Weekly introduces different cases and references relevant articles, with an interesting sidebar listing out all the upcoming capital defense cases and exonerations. As a whole, this broad range of websites has provided not only the informational aspects but also the opinionated aspects of the psychosocial study behind criminal justice and the legal system.

2 comments:

Anonymous said...

Thanks, Kim, for posting about my Underdog Blog. Blogging often helps me further along on the path to self-actualization/discovery/realization, including today's post about finding commonality with opponents: http://katzjustice.com/underdog/permalink/FelonyTrialLawyer.html

Thanks again.

Jon Katz
Criminal defense in Maryland, Virginia and D.C.
301-495-7755

Kirk Miles said...

Thank you for taking the time to explain why you chose each link for your linkroll and analyzing its strengths and weaknesses. It helps a lot for a reader like myself who is relatively uneducated when it comes to the law and what resources are best to keep up to date on what is happening in the legal world. I liked the fact that you used a variety of resources, rather than just many blogs or news sources that concentrate on similar topics. For example, you include links in what I would classify as four major categories: wrongful conviction, general news, general opinion (blogs), and anti-death penalty.

I can tell from the types of sources you chose that the major theme of your blog is meant to be injustice in the legal systems or the downfalls of the legal system. I think this is great. It is so easy to just sit back and accept everything that the legal system enforces, never questioning anything at all. Challenging the system is what makes this country great and is what keeps our government in check.

Also, thank you for linking to the websites as you referenced them throughout the blog. I know it would be easy to just reference your linkroll, but I was surprised at how much more I was inclined to visit each website when the link was right in front of me rather than having to go to the linkroll to visit it. As a result, I feel like I got a better sense of what your resources are about and actually learned some things about the legal system from reading the headlines each time I went on a site.

The only way I could see this entry being improved is to spread it out a little bit. I know that you wanted to go through and describe each of the resources you found, but I found myself getting lost in a sea of words at points because everything was so dense. To be honest, I am not sure how you would improve that without making an unnecessarily long post, but it was just an issue I had.

Thanks again for an informative post on the legal news resources available online. I think that, just because it is not prevalent in everyday life, law seems to often get ignored by people. This is the last thing we should do since it affects almost every aspect of our lives. Hopefully more people will continue to read your blog, as I am sure I will, and it will help raise awareness of the issues in law today.

 
Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 3.0 Unported License.